Cars / The Desk
Collector Car Portfolios Require Rigorous Carry Cost Documentation as Holding Periods Lengthen
While annual transactions remain in the billions, a stabilizing market increases the time assets spend in custody, elevating storage and insurance risks for fiduciaries.

Managing a collector car portfolio involves looking past headline transaction volumes and actively documenting the rising carry costs associated with longer holding periods. As the market stabilizes after a volatile period, buyers have become increasingly selective, meaning assets remain in custody longer before an exit can be executed.
The scale of the market remains substantial, but transaction figures obscure the ongoing cost of ownership. CNBC documented online classic-car sales at $2.5 billion[1] and total auctions and online transactions at $4.8 billion[1] in 2025[1]. However, these capital flows do not account for the specialized storage, maintenance, and insurance needed to preserve the fair market value of high-performance assets during extended holding periods.
A market analysis by Classic.com shows that after a volatile period between 2020[2] and 2023,[2] the collector car market has settled into a new normal where wild price swings have been replaced by smaller monthly adjustments. Reduced buyer urgency has led to increased selectivity, causing the time vehicles spend sitting on dealer lots to reach its highest level in years, as published by Classic.com.[2] This extended time-to-sale directly increases the total carry cost, as assets are maintained in retail-ready condition for months longer than during the peak market periods of the early decade.
This prolonged holding period elevates the operational risks of custody, particularly regarding specialized storage and insurance. Hagerty outlines that operating a storage facility for these vehicles involves unique liabilities, which can be managed through specialized commercial policies that pay out true market value at the time of loss.[3] The insurer's policy guidelines indicate that a blanket policy with no vehicle-cap per limit protects exceptionally valuable individual assets without requiring manual individual adjustments.[3] Verifying these specific policy limits is a critical risk control to prevent unhedged physical damage exposure during storage.
Integrating these assets into a broader wealth strategy requires coordinating valuation assumptions across multiple purposes. J.P. Morgan Private Bank integrates trust and estate planning, specialty lending, and tax strategy into its advisory services.[4] When a collector car is held within a trust, the valuation used for insurance replacement may differ significantly from its net realizable value at auction. Fiduciaries can document these differences to prevent liquidity shortfalls during estate transitions or when using the vehicles as collateral for specialty lending.
Ultimately, the public record does not disclose a standardized formula for calculating the exact ratio of carry costs to asset value, as maintenance expenses vary widely by vehicle age and mechanical complexity. While younger buyers are increasingly targeting modern supercars that require specialized diagnostic equipment and factory-certified technicians, the market lacks centralized data on these ongoing maintenance premiums. Until advisory files include documented, asset-specific budgets for storage, insurance, and mechanical preservation, fiduciaries cannot accurately project the net realizable return of an automotive allocation.
Evidence limits: the valuation basis behind the figures is not disclosed in enough depth. On this record alone, a reader cannot establish which value -- for tax, insurance, collateral, succession, or sale -- should govern the decision.
Related Coverage
Pricing Culturecollectibles - Aug 29, 2026
Family Offices Face Liquidity Risks From Concentrated Passion-Asset Portfolios
Managing massive wealth pools requires integrating highly concentrated, illiquid physical collections into broader balance-sheet risk and capital allocation planning.
Recent coverage involving the same entity.
collectibles - Aug 21, 2026
Family Office Art Collections Face Severe Underinsurance as Schedules Lag
With private wealth structures managing over $6 trillion in assets, outdated appraisals and rigid registration windows leave newly acquired masterpieces exposed to physical loss.
Recent coverage involving the same entity.
collectibles - Aug 21, 2026
Institutional Memorabilia Auctions Rely on Provenance to Support High-Value Estimates
Specialized insurance plans and direct-from-family consignments are emerging to protect collectors from the coverage gaps and valuation disputes that complicate secondary-market transactions.
Recent coverage involving the same entity.
art - Aug 14, 2026
Non-Itemizing Taxpayers Face Strict Caps on Direct Charitable Deductions
Under Internal Revenue Service guidelines, taxpayers who do not itemize face strict caps on cash contributions, excluding high-value physical art donations from standard deductions.
Recent coverage involving the same entity.
Sources
- 01
Cnbc
Classic-car market poised for strong 2026, says Hagerty CEOSource passage
The strength in the classic-car market is expected to continue in 2026, Hagerty CEO McKeel Hagerty told CNBC. The biggest driver is a new generation of collectors, who are more comfortable buying online, with online classic-car sales surging 12% this year to $2.5 billion, according to Hagerty. Younger buyers also want younger cars, and high-performance supercars of the '90s and later are drawing more interest. A version of this article first appeared in CNBC's Inside Wealth newsletter with Robert Frank, a weekly guide to the high-net-worth investor and consumer. Sign up to receive future editions, straight to your inbox. The strength in the classic-car market is expected to continue in 2026 as a new generation of collectors revs up demand, said the CEO of Hagerty. Auctions and online sales of collectible cars surged 10% in 2025 to $4.8 billion, according to Hagerty, the classic-car insurance company and collector platform. Hagerty CEO McKeel Hagerty said based on the sales pipeline and activity in the private classic-car market, demand appears strong for next year. "We've seen a lot of momentum on the private side," Hagerty told CNBC . "We're seeing a lot of private transactions take place of very significant cars, of all kinds, of all ages. We're looking forward to 2026." The biggest driver is a new generation of collectors. As baby boomers age out of the market and downsize,
- 02
Classic
6 months of the 2025 Market in 4 Charts - CLASSIC.COMSource passage
Following a volatile period between 2020 and 2023, the collector car market in 2025 has settled into a new normal. Wild price swings have been replaced by more modest changes and ultimately more sustainable conditions, which should be welcome news for enthusiasts, if not newer investors. Here are four charts from Hagerty that help tell the story. From 2023 through 2024, the collector car market gave back a lot of its COVID-era gains. That retreat has continued in 2025, but monthly changes are increasingly smaller, according to the Hagerty Market Index. Although the market is now right around the same level it was at the beginning of 2022, it appears to be locking into a new level. As the market settles, pricing has become more predictable. The average auction sale price is essentially unchanged from a year ago, as is the average asking price from collector car dealers. Even though the average list price has fallen 9% from its 2023 highwater mark, monthly adjustments so far this year have been much smaller compared to 2024. Again, the cooling market appears to be settling into stability. Even though the market is settling, buyers aren’t. Some dealers call it “selectivity”, others call it “patience” or “pickiness”, but no matter how you view it, more consistent pricing has resulted in reduced urgency. Enthusiasts have noticed that the market is equalizing, and they are willing to
- 03
Hagerty
Classic & Collector Car Storage InsuranceSource passage
Considering how much people love their collector vehicles, operating a storage facility can be a huge responsibility, exposing you to unique risks and challenges. That’s where Hagerty can help – by customizing insurance coverage to meet the highly specialized needs of your business. A storage policy with Hagerty pays out true market value at time of loss, and we rely on our vehicle and valuation expertise to determine accurate, up-to-date values. A policy with us also provides reassurance to your clients should you be liable for any damages A one-limit blanket policy with Hagerty means you won’t need to call in and cover each car individually. If you end up with an especially valuable car, you won’t need to worry whether it’s protected for its true value. With a blanket policy, there’s no vehicle-cap per limit. Actual loss sustained for business interruption * Less any deductible and/or salvage value, if retained by you. Agreed value includes all taxes and fees unless prohibited by state law. Hagerty determines final risk acceptance. Some coverage not available in all states. This is a general description of coverage. All coverage is subject to policy provisions, exclusions and endorsements.
- 04
Jpmorgan
J.P. Morgan Private Advisory | J.P. Morgan Private Bank U.S.Source passage
* What We Do * Who We Serve * Insights & Advice * About Us The Private Bank’s mission is to build, preserve & transform our client’s wealth. * Cyber Advisory * Executive Advisory * Family and Family Office Advisory * Life Insurance * Philanthropy * Private Business Advisory * Retirement and Asset Location * Tax Strategy * Trust & Estate Planning * Wealth Strategy * Investment Management * Outsourced CIO * Sustainable Investing * Alternative Investments * Annuities * Currencies, Commodities & Rates * Equities * Fixed Income * Business Banking * Banking Client Experiences * Online & Mobile Banking * Personal Banking * Real Estate Lending * Securities-Based Lending * Specialty Lending We work with a variety of clients to help them achieve their unique ambitions. Our world-class economists, strategists, and investment specialists share their timely ideas and perspectives. * Mid-Year Outlook * Global Investment Strategy View * Eye on the Market * Market Thoughts * Ideas & Insights * Top Market Takeaways * Family Office Report * Principal Discussions Report We have worked with clients for more than 200 years to help them achieve their unique ambitions. * What We Do The Private Bank’s mission is to build, preserve & transform our client’s wealth. * Who We Serve We work with a variety of clients to help them achieve their unique ambitions. * Insights & Advice Our world-class economists